1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516 Investor or Owner-User Opportunity in West Haven

$1,250,000 $40.05 / SF

1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT: retail property for sale, photo 1 of 2

1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT: retail property for sale, photo 2 of 2

1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516

For Sale Details

$1,250,000
$40.05 / SF

Property Type Retail

Sale Type Owner-User, Investment

Status Under Deposit
Created 01/23/26
Updated 06/03/26

About 1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516

Investment or owner-user opportunity. Profitable 31,208 SF building with two spaces leased to tenants plus a large basement workshop. Established tile and flooring business on the main level. Pool hall and café is licensed for food and alcohol. Lower level is currently a wood shop occupied by owner/landlord. Rental potential of the lower level. Fully sprinklered. Outside lights and sign metered. Ample parking. Ideal location on the West Haven and Orange town lines. Easy access to I-95 at Exit 42 (Saw Mill Road).

Building Details

Tenancy: Multitenant
Building Area (SF): 31,208
Year Built: 1954
Number of Stories: 1
Number of Buildings: 2

Land Details

Acreage: 0.94
Sewage System: Public Sewer
Water System: Public Water

Documents for 1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516

1167 Orange Avenue West Haven Lombardo Russell.pdf

The Retail property at 1167 Orange Avenue, West Haven, CT 06516 is currently available for sale. Contact Richard Lombardo from H. Pearce Real Estate Co., Inc. for more information.

More like this: Retail Property for Sale in New Haven County (3)· Retail Property for Sale in Connecticut (10)· Commercial Real Estate for Sale in West Haven (2)· Commercial Real Estate for Sale in New Haven County (8)· All listings from H. Pearce Real Estate Co., Inc. (10)

About this area: West Haven, CT

Conn-Comp market snapshot

Retail sales in New Haven County, last 12 months

103

sales recorded

$135

median price per SF

$107 - $196

middle half, per SF

7.95%

average mortgage rate

West Haven has too few retail sales in Conn-Comp to report separately, so these are the numbers for New Haven County. Median sale price $815,000. 53% of sales were financed, average loan 78% of price. Median price per SF up 6% from the prior 12 months. October 2025 through September 2026. Source: Conn-Comp Sales Data, verified Connecticut sales and recorded mortgages. For verified sales data, use Sales Data Login

West Haven's commercial property is concentrated along the Boston Post Road (US 1), Campbell Avenue and Route 34, with industrial and distribution property along Frontage Road near I-95 and Sawmill Road. Education and health care are the largest job sectors, led by the University of New Haven and the VA Connecticut medical center. A Metro-North station opened in West Haven in 2013.

Population	55,351
Jobs located here	15,660
Largest employers	VA Medical Center, Glanbia Nutritionals, University of New Haven, Yale University, MacDermid Alpha
Highways	I-95, US 1, Route 34, Route 122, Route 162
People within a 45-minute drive	1,521,566
Median household income	$74,382
County	New Haven County